Follow Us:

 

Cirsium pallidum - Wooton.&Standl.

Common Name Pale Thistle
Family Asteraceae or Compositae
USDA hardiness 4-8
Known Hazards Spines are sharp and require careful handling. Gloves are recommended during harvest. As with all thistles, proper identification is essential.
Habitats Stream banks, montane meadows, and damp soil in montane coniferous forests at elevations from 2,100 - to 3,700 metres[270 ].
Range South-western N. America - Arizona, Colrado and New Mexico.
Edibility Rating    (2 of 5)
Other Uses    (2 of 5)
Weed Potential No
Medicinal Rating    (1 of 5)
Care (info)
Fully Hardy Moist Soil Full sun
Cirsium pallidum Pale Thistle


W.L. Wagner @ USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database
Cirsium pallidum Pale Thistle

 

Translate this page:

Summary

Cirsium pallidum is a synonym of Cirsium parryi. Cirsium parryi is a biennial plant growing from a taproot; it produces a basal cluster of leaves and an erect flowering stem that can be 50 - 200cm or more tall[270 ]. The plant is harvested from the wild for local use as a food, medicine and source of materials. It is native to Arizona, Colorado, and New Mexico. Parry’s thistle is unusual among thistles in that only its seeds are reported edible, used as a calorie-dense but bitter resource. It grows in USDA Zones 4–8 and is not invasive.


Physical Characteristics

 icon of manicon of flower
Cirsium pallidum is a BIENNIAL growing to 1 m (3ft 3in) by 0.5 m (1ft 8in).
See above for USDA hardiness. It is hardy to UK zone 5. The species is hermaphrodite (has both male and female organs) and is pollinated by Bees, flies, Lepidoptera (Moths & Butterflies), beetles. The plant is self-fertile.
Suitable for: light (sandy), medium (loamy) and heavy (clay) soils. Suitable pH: mildly acid, neutral and basic (mildly alkaline) soils. It cannot grow in the shade. It prefers moist soil.

UK Hardiness Map US Hardiness Map

Synonyms

Carduus gilensis Wooton & Standl. Carduus inornatus Wooton & Standl. Carduus pallidus Wooton & Standl. Carduus parryi Greene. Carduus viridiflorus Greene. C. gilense Wooton & Standl. C. inornatum Wooton & Standl. C. parryi Petr. C. parryi subsp. mogollonicum Schaack & Goodwin. C. parryi subsp. viridiflorum (Greene) Petr. Cnicus parryi A.Gray.

Plant Habitats

 Cultivated Beds;

Edible Uses

Edible Parts: Oil  Seed
Edible Uses: Oil

A seed-focused edible thistle, useful primarily for its nutritious, toastable seeds. Edible Uses & Rating: The seeds are the primary edible part and represent the main value of this species. Roots are not considered edible and are generally lacking in the thick, starchy taproots seen in biennial thistles. Stems and leaves are technically edible but are impractical due to spines and poor texture. As a food plant, Parry’s thistle ranks as a moderate-quality wild food, valuable mainly as a seed source [2-3]. Taste, Processing & Kitchen Notes: Parry’s thistle seeds are enclosed within hard cypselae topped with feathery pappi. When raw, the flavor is bland to mildly bitter. Toasting significantly improves palatability by weakening the shells and reducing bitter resins. Toasted seeds develop a nutty, roasted flavor and can be eaten whole, with the shells either swallowed or spat out. Boiling produces a soft, porridge-like consistency, especially if shells are included, yielding a bran-like texture [2-3]. Seasonality (Phenology): Flowering typically occurs in mid- to late summer at high elevations. Seeds mature from late summer into early autumn and may persist on the plant for several weeks, extending the harvest window. Safety & Cautions (Food Use): Spines are sharp and require careful handling. Gloves are recommended during harvest. As with all thistles, proper identification is essential. Harvest & Processing Workflow: Harvest seed heads once they dry and begin to loosen. Remove pappi by rubbing or winnowing. Toast seeds gently in a covered pan to prevent scattering. Consume whole or grind lightly after cooking [2-3]. Cultivar/Selection Notes: No cultivars are known. Look-Alikes & Confusion Risks: Parry’s thistle resembles other montane Cirsium species. Confusion is generally harmless, as most native thistles have similar edible uses, but avoid non-Cirsium thistle-like plants such as knapweeds (Centaurea). Traditional / Indigenous Use Summary: Seeds were reportedly gathered by Navajo and other southwestern Indigenous groups, though documentation is limited. The focus on seeds rather than roots distinguishes this species from many other thistles. Seed - cooked[105, 177]. It can be eaten boiled or ground into a powder and used with cereal flours to make bread etc[61, 257, K]. Parry’s thistle (Cirsium parryi), also called Mogollon, Cloudcroft, Gila, or pale thistle, is native to the mountains of the southwestern United States. Unlike most thistles, which have edible roots, stems, or receptacles, the only reported edible part of this species is its seeds. The seeds are enclosed in dry fruits (cypselae) topped with hairy plumes. They are a concentrated source of calories, though often bitter from resins. Traditionally, thistle seeds could be toasted to mask bitterness, eaten whole in their shells, or boiled into a mush. While they are small and tedious to gather, Parry’s thistle seeds—like those of other thistles—were valued for their energy content, especially in survival or subsistence contexts. Other parts of this species are not reported as food, making it unusual within its genus, where roots and stems are often useful [2-3].

References   More on Edible Uses

Medicinal Uses

Plants For A Future can not take any responsibility for any adverse effects from the use of plants. Always seek advice from a professional before using a plant medicinally.
Diuretic

The roots are diuretic[257].

References   More on Medicinal Uses

The Bookshop: Edible Plant Books

Our Latest books on Perennial Plants For Food Forests and Permaculture Gardens in paperback or digital formats.

Food Forest Plants for Hotter Conditions: 250+ Plants For Tropical Food Forests & Permaculture Gardens.
Edible Tropical Plants

Food Forest Plants for Hotter Conditions: 250+ Plants For Tropical Food Forests & Permaculture Gardens.

More
Plants for Your Food Forest: 500 Plants for Temperate Food Forests & Permaculture Gardens.
Edible Temperate Plants

Plants for Your Food Forest: 500 Plants for Temperate Food Forests & Permaculture Gardens.

More
PFAF have eight books available in paperback and digital media.
More Books

PFAF have eight books available in paperback and digital formats. Browse the shop for more information.

Shop Now

Other Uses

Oil

The seed of all species of thistles yields a good oil by expression[4]. No details of potential yields etc are given[K].

Special Uses

References   More on Other Uses

Cultivation details

Parry’s thistle is a specialized montane thistle offering nutritious seeds rather than roots. While not as versatile as other thistles, it remains a dependable wild food in mountain regions. Growing Conditions: Parry’s thistle prefers cool, moist mountain environments with well-drained soils. It commonly occurs in open meadows, forest clearings, and montane slopes, often associated with ponderosa pine, fir, or spruce communities. Habitat & Range: This species is native to the mountainous regions of Arizona, New Mexico, and adjacent areas of Colorado. It is most common at mid- to high elevations in the Mogollon Rim, Gila Mountains, and similar ranges. Size & Landscape Performance: Plants usually reach 50–80 cm in height but may grow taller in favorable conditions. It occurs as scattered individuals or small groups rather than dense stands. Cultivation (Horticulture): Parry’s thistle is not cultivated and has no ornamental or agricultural value. It is primarily of interest to foragers and botanists. Pests & Problems: Parry’s thistle is relatively pest-free. Harsh mountain climates and spines deter most herbivores. Pollination: Pollinated by bees and other generalist insects adapted to high-elevation environments. Identification & Habit: Parry’s thistle typically forms a basal rosette of large, deeply lobed leaves during its first growing season. Leaves are pale green to grayish and armed with stout spines along the margins. In its reproductive stage, the plant produces one or more erect flowering stems bearing large, showy flower heads. The flowers are usually pale lavender to whitish-purple, giving rise to the common name “pale thistle.” The involucral bracts are strongly spined, and the overall plant has a lighter, more silvery appearance than many lowland thistles.

References   Carbon Farming Information and Carbon Sequestration Information

Temperature Converter

Type a value in the Celsius field to convert the value to Fahrenheit:

Fahrenheit:

image

The PFAF Bookshop

Plants For A Future have a number of books available in paperback and digital form. Book titles include Edible Plants, Edible Perennials, Edible Trees,Edible Shrubs, Woodland Gardening, and Temperate Food Forest Plants. Our new book is Food Forest Plants For Hotter Conditions (Tropical and Sub-Tropical).

Shop Now

Plant Propagation

Seed - sow early spring or autumn in situ. Germination usually takes place within 2 - 8 weeks at 20°c[164]. Division in spring or autumn.

Other Names

If available other names are mentioned here

Parry’s thistle (Cirsium parryi), also called Mogollon, Cloudcroft, Gila, or pale thistle

Native Range

NORTHERN AMERICA: United States (Colorado, New Mexico, Arizona

Weed Potential

Right plant wrong place. We are currently updating this section. Please note that a plant may be invasive in one area but may not in your area so it's worth checking.

Not Invasive.

Conservation Status

IUCN Red List of Threatened Plants Status :

Related Plants
Latin NameCommon NameHabitHeightHardinessGrowthSoilShadeMoistureEdibleMedicinalOther
Cirsium acaulonStemless ThistlePerennial0.3 4-8  LMHNM012
Cirsium amplexifoliumDakiba-Hime-AzamiPerennial1.5 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium arizonicumArizona thistleBiennial1.0 4-8 FLMHNDM302
Cirsium arvenseCreeping Thistle, Canada thistlePerennial0.9 3-8 FLMHNM222
Cirsium brevicaule Perennial1.0 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium brevistylumIndian Thistle, Clustered thistlePerennial1.8 0-0  LMHSNM302
Cirsium buergeri Perennial1.8 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium chinense Perennial0.8 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium coreanum Perennial0.0 -  LMHSNM102
Cirsium dipsacolepis Perennial1.0 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium drummondiiDwarf thistleBiennial0.4 4-8 FLMNDM301
Cirsium eatoniEaton's ThistlePerennial0.5 -  LMHNDM112
Cirsium eduleEdible ThistlePerennial2.0 6-9  LMHNM302
Cirsium eriophorumWooly ThistleBiennial1.5 5-9  LMHNM202
Cirsium foliosumElk thistlePerennial0.6 5-9  LMHNMWe302
Cirsium hookerianumWhite ThistlePerennial1.5 -  LMHNM202
Cirsium japonicumNo-Azami, Japanese thistleBiennial/Perennial0.9 5-9  LMHNM222
Cirsium kamtschaticumKamchatka thistlePerennial1.8 0-0  LMHNM102
Cirsium lepskyle Perennial0.0 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium lineare Perennial1.0 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium maackii Perennial1.0 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium maritimum Perennial0.4 -  LMHNM102
Cirsium neomexicanumNew Mexico thistlePerennial1.0 4-8 FLMNM301
Cirsium nipponicum Perennial1.5 -  LMHNM112
Cirsium occidentaleCobwebby Thistle, Snowy thistle, Compact cobwebby thistlePerennial1.0 8-11  LMHNDM202
Cirsium ochrocentrumYellow Spined ThistlePerennial1.0 4-8  LMHNDM322
Cirsium oleraceumCabbage ThistlePerennial1.2 -  LMHSNMWe202
Cirsium oligophyllum Perennial1.0 -  LMHNM202
Cirsium palustreMarsh ThistleBiennial1.5 4-8  LMHSNMWe202
12

Growth: S = slow M = medium F = fast. Soil: L = light (sandy) M = medium H = heavy (clay). pH: A = acid N = neutral B = basic (alkaline). Shade: F = full shade S = semi-shade N = no shade. Moisture: D = dry M = Moist We = wet Wa = water.

 

Now available: Food Forest Plants for Mediterranean Conditions 350+ Perennial Plants For Mediterranean and Drier Food Forests and Permaculture Gardens. [Paperback and eBook]

This is the third in Plants For A Future's series of plant guides for food forests tailored to specific climate zones. Following volumes on temperate and tropical ecosystems, this book focuses on species suited to Mediterranean conditions—regions with hot, dry summers and cool, wet winters, often facing the added challenge of climate change.

Read More

Mediterranean Food Forest Book

Expert comment

Author

Wooton.&Standl.

Botanical References

Links / References

For a list of references used on this page please go here

Readers comment

Add a comment

If you have important information about this plant that may help other users please add a comment or link below. Only comments or links that are felt to be directly relevant to a plant will be included. If you think a comment/link or information contained on this page is inaccurate or misleading we would welcome your feedback at [email protected]. If you have questions about a plant please use the Forum on this website as we do not have the resources to answer questions ourselves.

* Please note: the comments by website users are not necessarily those held by PFAF and may give misleading or inaccurate information.

To leave a comment please Register or login here All comments need to be approved so will not appear immediately.

Subject : Cirsium pallidum  
© 2010, Plants For A Future. Plants For A Future is a charitable company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales. Charity No. 1057719, Company No. 3204567.